posts >> publuis > william > nikolai > bradley
_________________________________________________________
Publuis
There are two essential functions of a sovereign nation; (1) the rule of law and (2) established borders. No person foreign or domestic can be beyond reproach of the law. In addition without enforcement laws provide only guidelines. Clearly defining where legal jurisdiction extends is equally necessary. Without laws or borders no government, of any kind, can employ sovereign order. Consequently, illegal immigration calls into question these basic principals.
When an immigrant crosses an established border illegally (s)he challenges the fundamental pillars on which a nation is built. Its laws are called into action and its continuity is compromised. There exist established avenues for legal immigration, for myriad reasons. Legal migration upholds the rule of law and border continuity.
Therefore, migrants who break the established law and compromise borders should be held in account for their actions. Moreover, those who have evaded enforcement of established law need to be rooted-out and accountable also. Enforcing immigration law is not about xenophobia or elitism. Rather it is paramount to preserving a nation as such.
Deportation of those currently living illegally within a nation’s border is not a sound solution, neither is jailing them. Instead, holding them accountable to the law through financial penalty, forfeiture of certain privileges and or a probationary period under the supervision of law enforcement are better solutions.
Equally, strategies to reinforce the integrity of a nation’s border must be implemented while at the same time prosecuting law breakers. It is not enough to build a wall of deterrence.
_________________________________________________________
William
It wasn’t that long ago that the first immigrants to America, fleeing religious persecution, landed in Plymouth. In fact the larger part of 400 years of American immigration policy have consisted of merely proving identity within a greater context of expanding borders. The French summed up what was the American immigration policy when they wrote on the Statue of Liberty: “give us your poor, your tired, your huddled masses longing to be free…”
Until recently, it was recognized that the U.S. was a society of immigrants. But those days are largely gone as our borders are now fixed and quotas along with application processes establish who may and may not enter. Over the last few hundred years, the main influx of immigrants braved harsh conditions to escape deplorable conditions in their respective homelands. From the potato famine to dismal Latin American economies (of which we’ve had a hand), the search for opportunity in America has come at a great social and personal price – even costing some their lives.
Our current immigration predicament is important to see in light of its historical context. Our borders have not been well enforced, and too often have we looked the other way when in need of crop pickers. The solution aught to be a mix of grace and truth. Grace extended in the form of guest worker programs or a road to amnesty for those who are already here. And truth in stronger borders and penalties paid for illegal entry. If those two things were to happen, subjects like drivers’ licenses, social service strain and unpaid taxes wouldn’t continue to be issues. We have a responsibility to these people in light of our history, our own culpability, and our proclaimed motto.
_________________________________________________________
Nikolai
In 1918 Theodore Roosevelt said, “Every immigrant who comes here should be required within five years to learn English or leave the country.” It’s become apparent that illegal immigration is a major issue in the upcoming presidential election. All of the candidates believe there needs to be a better way of protecting our borders. What to do with those already here and what to do with the current process of making immigration legal is where the difference lies. Some say that illegal immigrants should be allowed complete amnesty, and others believe in immediate deportation.
Action needs to be taken regardless of how the immigrants end up in our country. I agree with President Theodore Roosevelt’s quote saying immigrants should be required to learn our native language. If they’re looking to call the United States their home, then they should be making the extra effort to complete the naturalization process as quickly as possible. I also believe that the government should be aiding as much as they can. Providing either free or affordable education for the immigrants is one way of achieving this. How are we expecting immigrants to learn our language and history if nobody is there to help them along the way? Immigrants should be given the same rights and responsibilities as birth citizens. They also need to take the bad with the good, i.e. be held accountable to our laws and pay taxes! To most countries around the world the United States is known to be the land of opportunity. Its time we started acting like it.
_________________________________________________________
Bradley
So, what ever happened to personal responsibility?!
EGO sum conscius lex, tamen EGO sum sumo ut effrego is usquam. It’s Latin, yeah I went there again. In English it translates to, “I am aware of the law, but I am choosing to break it anyway.” Think about it. Take it in. Swish it around. Gargle it. Spit it out. Then take another drink.
Let’s say I wanted to go to Russia, because that’s where all the good begging jobs are. I couldn’t just hop on a plane or boat and simply arrive in the mother land; there are certain protocols that need to be followed that are set up for a reason. (mostly so I don’t get myself owned by the KGB) The same is also true for those that want to come to The U.S. If one makes the transition legally, it will absolutely pay off for all parties involved. The U.S. gov’t will get it’s taxes and the parent won’t be deported and ripped away from their 5 year old.
Of course I’m aware that there are already thousands of illegal aliens here in the states and our economy “relies” on them. But this most certainly does not excuse the fact that they are here illegally. Meaning, against the law.
The United States needs to crack down on employers who hire these aliens, and penalize them for breaking the law. The U.S. should also provide a very strict, zero tolerance path to citizenship. Clear guidelines for the aliens to follow and qualifications they need to meet, or be deported. Amnesty would be saying, “Our laws mean nothing, do as you please.” (then again, laws are only made valid by those that follow them)
So give us your poor, your tired, your huddled masses, but let’s do this legally.